Super Mario Kart nearly didn’t make our SNES rankings list because Joe called it “just a racing game with shells.” This led to me hosting an impromptu Mario Kart tournament over Zoom where Joe finished dead last in every single race, after which he quietly agreed it deserved inclusion. Sometimes you need to prove your point through public humiliation.
I’ve been playing Mario Kart since 1992 when my neighbor got it for Christmas and we spent the entire winter break destroying our friendship one race at a time. I’ve put hundreds of hours into the series across every console. And I can tell you definitively: Super Mario Kart is where it all started, and it’s still one of the best in the series for pure competitive chaos.
What Makes Super Mario Kart Special
Developer: Nintendo | Released: August 1992 (North America)
Super Mario Kart created the kart racing genre essentially from scratch. Nintendo took their popular characters, put them in go-karts, added items for mayhem, and created something that looked simple but had genuine depth. Mode 7 graphics made the track rotate and scale in revolutionary ways for 1992. The result looked and felt unlike anything else on the SNES.
Eight racers are available: Mario, Luigi, Princess Peach, Yoshi, Bowser, Donkey Kong Jr., Koopa Troopa, and Toad. Each has different stats – weight, acceleration, and top speed. Light characters (Toad, Peach, Koopa) accelerate quickly but get knocked around easily. Heavy characters (Bowser, DK Jr.) have high top speed but terrible acceleration. Medium characters (Mario, Luigi, Yoshi) balance both stats.
This creates a genuine meta-game. Rainbow Road favors handling and acceleration over raw speed because one mistake sends you flying off the track. Bowser Castle needs power to push through hazards. Ghost Valley requires precision. Character choice matters based on track and play style, which adds strategic depth beyond “pick your favorite.”
The Track Design That Defined The Series
Twenty tracks across five cups (Mushroom, Flower, Star, Special, and Battle). Each track introduces distinct challenges and requires different approaches. The difficulty curve is perfect – Mushroom Cup teaches basics, Special Cup demands mastery.
Mario Circuit tracks are straightforward with few hazards – pure racing skill determines winners. Ghost Valley tracks have gaps in the floor that you can fall through, requiring precise driving. Donut Plains tracks have mud patches that slow you down. Bowser Castle has lava and Thwomp hazards. Rainbow Road is a nightmare of narrow paths with no guardrails where one mistake means plummeting into space.
The track design rewards learning optimal racing lines. Where to drift, where to use mushrooms, where to cut corners. On time trials, players discovered shortcuts – some intentional, some exploiting Mode 7 quirks. The skill ceiling is high enough that speedrunners still compete for records decades later.
Battle Mode deserves special mention. Four arenas where players try to pop each other’s balloons using items. Last kart with balloons wins. This mode created its own meta-game separate from racing. Block Fort’s structure creates ambush opportunities. Battle Course 1’s simplicity makes it pure skill competition. These battles destroyed friendships more efficiently than races ever could.
The Item Balance That Creates Chaos
Items are the soul of Mario Kart. They add randomness that keeps races exciting but don’t completely override skill. The item balance in Super Mario Kart is remarkably good considering this was the first attempt at the formula.
Green shells travel in straight lines – skill shots that reward good aim. Red shells home in on the racer ahead of you. Bananas can be dropped as traps or thrown forward. Mushrooms give speed boosts. Stars make you invincible and fast temporarily. Lightning shrinks all opponents. Coins give a small speed boost (they were removed in later games for good reason – they’re boring).
The item you receive depends on your position. First place gets defensive items like bananas and green shells. Last place gets powerful comeback items like stars and lightning. This rubber-banding keeps races competitive – the leader can’t run away completely, but they still have tools to defend their position.
The chaos comes from multiple items active simultaneously. Someone drops a banana, you swerve to avoid it and hit a green shell, get shrunk by lightning, recover just in time to get hit by a red shell. These chain reactions create memorable moments and keep every race unpredictable.
The Mode 7 Graphics That Impressed In 1992
Mode 7 was the SNES’s signature feature – hardware-based rotation and scaling of background layers. Super Mario Kart used it to create a pseudo-3D racing perspective. The track appeared to curve and rise/fall as you drove, even though technically it was just flat graphics being rotated and scaled.
By modern standards, Mode 7 looks primitive. The background layer is flat. Sprites don’t rotate with the camera angle. The draw distance is limited. But in 1992? This looked genuinely impressive. The illusion of 3D racing on a 2D console felt like magic.
The track hazards and obstacles are sprites that scale as you approach them. Thwomps, pipes, oil slicks, Piranha Plants – they all grow larger as you get closer, creating depth perception. The effect is somewhat convincing if you don’t think too hard about it.
The framerate holds steady even with eight racers and multiple items on screen. This was crucial for playability – racing games need consistent frame pacing or they become uncontrollable. Nintendo prioritized performance over visual fidelity, and it shows in how smoothly the game runs.
The Controls That Feel Right
Super Mario Kart’s controls are simple but effective. Accelerate, brake, use items, and powerslide. That’s it. No complex mechanics beyond learning to drift around corners for tighter lines and slight speed boosts.
The drift mechanics took practice to master. Tap brake while turning to start a slide. Hold the turn to maintain it. Let go at the right moment to straighten out. Good drifting is the difference between winning and placing mid-pack. The skill ceiling here is deceptively high – top players can drift through sections that seem impossible at first glance.
The SNES controller’s D-pad works well for the driving model. You’re not making subtle adjustments like a steering wheel – you’re making discrete left/right/up/down inputs. The digital nature of the D-pad suits this perfectly. Later Mario Kart games used analog sticks, but honestly, the D-pad still feels better for tight precision.
Why This Destroyed More Friendships Than Monopoly
The versus mode is where Super Mario Kart shows its true colors. Racing against the AI teaches you tracks and mechanics. Racing against humans reveals the game’s depth and ruthlessness.
Human opponents learn your patterns. They’ll save red shells for when you’re vulnerable. They’ll place bananas at corner exits where you always drift. They’ll time lightning to hit you on Rainbow Road’s narrowest section. The AI is predictable. Humans are monsters.
The comeback mechanics create drama. Someone pulls ahead with a star, you catch up with mushrooms, they block with a banana, you nail them with a green shell, they revenge-red-shell you immediately. Races stay competitive until the final lap, and anything can happen in those last moments.
Joe’s humiliation in our tournament wasn’t just about losing – it was about getting completely dominated by items he couldn’t defend against while we laughed. That experience built character. Also, it proved my point about the game deserving a top-ten spot, which was the real goal.
Does Super Mario Kart Hold Up Today?
For casual play with friends who appreciate retro games? Yes. The core loop is still fun. The items create chaos. The tracks are well-designed. Battle Mode especially holds up for quick competitive sessions.
For serious play? Modern Mario Kart games have surpassed it in every technical way. Mario Kart 8 Deluxe has better graphics, more tracks, better items, online play, and antigravity mechanics. Mario Kart DS improved the drifting. Mario Kart Wii added bikes and tricks.
But Super Mario Kart established the template. The character archetypes, the item system, the track themes, the Battle Mode – these all started here. Playing the original shows you how well-designed the foundation was, even if subsequent games built on it.
The Mode 7 graphics look dated but functional. The limited track selection compared to modern entries is noticeable. The AI rubberband is aggressive to the point of frustration. But the core gameplay remains solid enough to enjoy today if you approach it with appropriate expectations.
Why It’s Number Ten On Our List
Super Mario Kart sits at number ten on our SNES rankings because it created an entire genre and did so with remarkable polish. The games above it are more ambitious or innovative in specific ways, but Super Mario Kart’s influence on multiplayer gaming can’t be overstated.
During our crew debate, Joe’s initial resistance was understandable – compared to epic RPGs and innovative action games, a racing game seems less impressive. But after he experienced getting destroyed by items while we laughed, he understood. This game creates moments and memories through competitive chaos in ways most games don’t.
Tim appreciated the accessible but deep design. John briefly claimed Micro Machines on Amiga was better (nobody engaged with this). Carl was just happy we’d finally finished the list after three weeks of arguments.
The placement at number ten feels right. It’s the most “fun” game on the list rather than the most “important” or “artistic.” And sometimes pure fun deserves recognition.
The Legacy That Never Stopped
Super Mario Kart spawned a franchise that’s still Nintendo’s multiplayer flagship. Every console since has had a Mario Kart entry. The series has sold over 150 million copies total. The basic formula established in 1992 is still being used and refined today.
Beyond Nintendo, it created the kart racing genre. Crash Team Racing, Diddy Kong Racing, Sonic Racing, even military kart racers like Cel Damage – they all owe their existence to Super Mario Kart proving the concept worked.
The game established multiplayer design principles that influenced beyond racing games. Items that help losing players catch up. Quick, repeatable sessions. Accessible controls with hidden depth. These concepts appear in everything from Smash Bros to modern battle royales.
The Verdict
Super Mario Kart is the game that created kart racing and made competitive multiplayer gaming accessible to everyone. The item system creates chaos without completely overriding skill. The track design rewards learning optimal lines. The character variety adds strategic depth. Battle Mode is friendship-destroying perfection.
If you’ve never played it, approach it as a historical artifact that’s still fun. If you played it as a kid, replay it and appreciate the design work that made it timeless. If you love modern Mario Kart, go back and see where it all started.
This is how you create a new genre. This is how you make multiplayer gaming work. This is how you design chaos that feels fair enough to keep people coming back despite the frustration.
And yes, Joe, it absolutely deserved to make the list. Your performance in the tournament proved my point perfectly.
Rating: 9/10 – The kart racer that started it all
Return to our full SNES rankings →
Samuel’s been gaming since the Atari 2600 and still thinks 16-bit was the golden age. Between accounting gigs and parenting teens, he keeps the CRTs humming in his Minneapolis basement, writing about cartridge quirks, console wars, and why pixel art never stopped being beautiful.
